Oh
! Man, that solves everything! So it turns out - this entire time - the whole stocking drama was because they enjoyed arguing!
... except we have logs of him acting as a creep towards her. His on-and-off girlfriend eventually sorta turned around but I'll be honest, she shoulden't have, although this does show there's probably a good bit of truth to this retroactive history (only an abuse victim who wants more would be coming back to this shit).
Also I know this was so so long ago but I mean, you ever think that blacklisting someone from a popular addon - that a lot of people used - was a good way to deal with them instead of just say, banning the person from your own server? This feels like a weird precursor to his whole "I wanna monopolize the lolcow community!" plans